April 14, 2012
Toronto Star - Opinion Editorial
Dr. Danielle Martin
I don’t know about you, but in my house we don’t each buy our own toothpaste. It’s not a good use of money to have multiple small tubes scattered around the sink — not to mention the wasted time if each family member makes a separate trip to the drugstore. We agree on a brand, buy one big tube, and save our money and time. Ditto with planning meals: one person buys the groceries. We may each be responsible for feeding ourselves, but we all have access to whatever is in the fridge.
I share this just in case the prime minister and premiers do things differently at their houses and might find the approach instructive. Because it’s clear that when it comes to health-care policy, they’re wasting the family budget buying multiples of everything, and everyone is cooking a different dinner. To make matters worse, the person who’s supposed to be the head of the family has left an allowance on the table and gone on vacation. Indefinitely.
Whose job is it to co-ordinate health-care reform in Canada? Canadians expect our federal government to play that role. We want to know that wherever we live, we will have access to an equivalent basket of services. We want to know that our governments are buying in bulk whenever possible, maximizing savings. And we want assurances that some basic standards are being met from coast to coast to coast. Health care may be a provincial responsibility, but we know there’s a need for a family to co-ordinate its efforts.
So when the Harper government plunked a 6-per-cent escalator on the table and walked away from its role in health care, I was disappointed. And it seems I wasn’t the only one.
A recent Environics poll on health care showed a sea change from 10 years ago — 62 per cent of Canadians think that health care is about more than just money, it’s about what our leaders do with it. That’s up more than 20 per cent from 2002.
And the Senate report released last month, “Time for Transformative Change”, urged the federal government to take an active role in transforming the health-care system, and ensure that funding is used as an incentive for change. The report assessed the impact of the 2004 health accord, and showed clearly that a 2014 accord is needed to further improve our system.
Senator Art Eggleton echoed this point, saying that the federal government can’t just put the money on the table and walk away — it needs to be a key partner in leadership on health care.
Meanwhile, the 2012 federal budget cut Health Canada, and said nothing about meaningful change. The only nod to improving the system was a three-year, $6.5-million study on cost-effectiveness in health care.
But that ignores the mountains of evidence we already have about how to improve our health-care system while making it more efficient. It’s becoming baffling to Canadians as to why our federal government wouldn’t co-ordinate a national pharmacare system that could save billions. Everyone knows you get a better deal if you buy in bulk.
Cost-effectiveness can also be found by making the right choices around a more caring and appropriate system for our elderly. We need a spectrum of continuing care, from long-term care, assisted living, home care and palliative care that alleviates pressures on hospitals and puts the patient first. We should be shifting as a nation toward a system that puts less pressure on acute resources, and respects the choices of our seniors.
The Environics poll also shows that those Canadians who have the most frequent interactions with the health-care system are most pessimistic about it. We’re not doing as well as we could be for people with chronic conditions, and improving community care and self-management is another win-win — it’s cost-effective, and better for patients.
But the poll also showed that Canadians are still optimistic about our health-care system. Most of us believe it’s the best in the world. We’re happy with a publicly funded system. A lot of us think that it takes care of our most vulnerable, and that it will be there for us if we’re ill or injured.
It makes you wonder why the federal government wouldn’t want to fight for that system, and lead the transformation needed to keep Canada ahead of the pack on health care. Canadians take pride in their health-care system — so should their government.
Danielle Martin is a family physician in Toronto and Chair of Canadian Doctors for Medicare.
Read article on the Toronto Star website here.
Related Articles/Posts
- Killing the Health Council bad for Canada’s health...April 16, 2013 TORONTO- The federal government’s move to defund the Health Council of Canada is another clear example of its determination to abandon Canada’s ...
- People to watch: Danielle Martin...December 30, 2012 Toronto Star Theresa Boyle It’s Dr. Danielle Martin’s turn to lead the weekly grand rounds education session at Women’s College Hospital, a...
- More or less Medicine: Danielle on the Agenda Feb ...February 5, 2013 Dr. Danielle Martin appeared as a panelist on The Agenda with Steve Paikin to contriubte to a discussion on the treatment of patients and whet...
- OP-ED: Private delivery acceptable when key criter...January 25, 2013 The Medical Post Opinion Editorial by Dr. Danielle Martin Canadian Doctors for Medicare says it opposed Shouldice Hospital sale but not all ...
- Doctors urge Health Care Action Plan to thwart ‘lo...February 28, 2011 Globe and Mail Gloria Galloway and Lisa Priest Doctors say federal leadership is needed to avert a looming health-care crisis and that bett...
- Sale of for-profit surgery clinic hits snag, resig...November 4, 2012 National Post Tom Blackwell The unusual saga of a for-profit clinic that does surgery at taxpayer expense took a surprising turn Friday, as ...
- Health Ministers meeting in Halifax...November 25, 2011 Health Ministers meeting in Halifax Canadian Doctors for Medicare was hard at work last week as our nation’s health ministers gathered in Ha...
- Don’t Walk Away: Why Federal Leadership on Health ...With its recent announcement on health transfers, the federal government has declared that it plans to cut a cheque, and then just walk away from its resp...
- Many struggle to pay for prescriptions ...January 16, 2012 Globe and Mail Andre Picard On in four Canadians who do not have drug insurance are unable to afford to take their prescription drugs as dir...
- Federal Leadership on Health Care Matters - July 2...Presented as part of a First Aid Kit for Canadian Health Care at the Council of the Federation in July 2013. Canadians expect better from our federal governmen...
- One in 10 Canadians cannot afford prescription med...January 16, 2012 CTVNews.ca Angela Mulholland One in 10 Canadians have problems affording their prescription medication, often because they don't have insura...
- Make Shift Happen: Mobilizing the Power of the Pub...On April 20, 2012, Danielle Martin spoke at Public Interest Alberta's Conference Make Shift Happen: Mobilizing the Power of the Public. Click on the link below ...
- Tory government will end funding of body that over...April 16, 2013 Toronto Star By: Steve Rennie OTTAWA—The Health Council of Canada will no longer receive money from the federal government to keep tabs on ...
- Under red umbrellas, Canadians to stand up for hea...July 17, 2012 Montreal Gazette Natalie Stechyson Canadians standing under red umbrellas to symbolize they're covered under medicare will assemble in cities a...
- Health Council cut will splinter system, erode car...April 17, 2013 iPolitics By: Wayne Kondro Canada's health care system is on the fast track to becoming 14 splintered systems as the Harper government is clea...
- Quebec ranks second best in wait times ...December 4, 2012 Montreal Gazette Charlie Fidelman MONTREAL — Surgical wait times have fallen slightly, but Canadian patients continue to wait too long — a...
- Better home care and better pay for doctors urged ...May 2, 2011 CMAJ Even on a cold winter night, it seems Canadians can’t resist the promise of an earnest evening of debate over medicare reform: With 500 peo...
- Blood plasma clinics a sign of privatization in he...March 13, 2013 Toronto Star By: Theresa Boyle A group of doctors concerned about increasing privatization in Canada’s health-care system has added its voice ...
- Stop for-profit blood clinics, doctors urge ...March 13, 2013 CBC News Introducing a paid-donor system for blood products could compromise Canada's blood supply and is not justified, a group of physicians ...
- CTV: Dr. Dan Raza on the importance of a federal r...July 24, 2013 Watch CDM board member, Dr. Danyaal Raza speak about the importance of a federal role in health care. http://www.ctvnews.ca/video?binId=1.810415...